Header bruinvissen

Harbour porpoises at the Borssele wind farm

Are wind farms suitable habitats for harbour porpoises? Since 2021, researchers have been trying to answer this question at the Borssele offshore wind farm, partly built and operated by Blauwwind. The initial results are now available and look promising. Harbour porpoises are regularly spotted in this part of the Dutch North Sea.

Wozep research programme

Although wind farms play a vital role in the transition to clean and sustainable energy, the construction, operation and eventual dismantling of offshore wind turbines affect marine life. In 2016, the Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy commissioned Rijkswaterstaat, the executive agency of the Dutch Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management, to study the impact of wind farms on marine animals. As a result, the Wozep ecological programme was established. This research programme has been investigating the impact of the fully operational Borssele wind farm on harbour porpoises and other marine mammals since 2021.

Research overview

  • This study is part of the Wozep research programme and began in 2021
  • Harbour porpoises are monitored underwater by 14 monitoring stations
  • Aerial surveys observe harbour porpoises near the water surface
  • The research is taking place at the Borssele wind farm
  • The impact of different noise levels in the area is also being studied

Image: WOZEP / Waardenburg Ecology

Detecting click sounds

Harbour porpoises use click sounds for echolocation. Researchers detect these sounds using dedicated monitoring stations at the wind farm and nearby. When combined with aerial surveys, this provides insight into the number of harbour porpoises in the area. Previous research has shown that these mammals avoid wind farms during the construction phase.

“Harbour porpoises have very sensitive hearing and are disturbed by noise in their environment”, explains Marin van Regteren, a marine ecologist at Eneco, which is part of the Blauwwind consortium. But what happens post-construction?

Impact of operational wind farms on harbour porpoises

The research programme is examining the impact of wind farms and underwater noise on harbour porpoises. This specific aspect of the programme is looking at whether these marine mammals return to an area after a wind farm has been constructed. Harbour porpoises are particularly affected by pile driving, the process where wind turbine foundations are driven into the seabed.

Marin says, “But there’s no pile driving during the operational phase, and, so far, our research indicates that harbour porpoises have indeed returned to the area.”

More harbour porpoises within the wind farm than outside

To determine whether there are fewer harbour porpoises within the wind farm, data from outside the site was needed. The researchers recorded the number of harbour porpoises a few kilometres north of the wind turbines. They used a reference site roughly the same size as the Borssele wind farm, with similar water depth, seawater temperature and distance to shore — but with no wind turbines.

“We found virtually no difference in the number of harbour porpoises between the two areas”, reveals Marin. “If anything, our monitoring stations detected slightly more of them within the wind farm than outside.”

Borssele quieter than immediate surroundings

Wind turbines also generate noise when operational. But as Marin points out, the wider Borssele area is generally busy and noisy: “Extending approximately from the Port of Rotterdam to the Port of Antwerp, the area sees a lot of shipping traffic and other activity. Many people use this stretch of sea for a variety of purposes.”

What does this mean when it comes to noise levels? “That’s the interesting part. Average noise levels turned out to be between two and six decibels lower within the wind farm than outside. There’s less shipping traffic and therefore less noise.”

Key findings

  • After the construction phase, harbour porpoises returned to the wind farm
  • There was no significant difference in the number of harbour porpoises between the wind farm and outside
  • Noise levels at the Borssele III/IV wind farm are on average 2 to 6 dB lower compared to the immediate surroundings


Image: WOZEP / Waardenburg Ecology

Wind farms as safe havens

Do these findings suggest that wind farms may serve as safe havens for marine animals? “There are definitely some positive aspects to highlight”, says Marin. “We have already discussed the noise levels. Furthermore, bottom trawling is not permitted at wind farms. So, you won’t see any large fishing nets being pulled along the seafloor in these places, making them relatively peaceful.”

However, Marin stresses that additional research is needed to determine the exact impact of wind farms on harbour porpoises: “But it’s a good sign that they seem to return to an area after construction is complete.”

Open research questions

The research has so far focused on the impact of wind farms on harbour porpoises during and after the construction phase. What remains to be studied is the period before construction, prior to development. This will be investigated before one of the next wind farms is constructed. “Only then will we be able to tell if the presence of a wind farm makes a habitat less appealing to harbour porpoises”, explains Marin. “Or more attractive, as the case may be. We won’t know until we study it.”